It's been a year since Peter Puckett's adventure in Evermore, so when a magic spell backfires on his friend James causing the boy to lose his memory, Peter uses the opportunity to travel back to the fantastic world to find the Enchanted Chalice, a miraculous cup that will save James.

​

Accompanied by the dancing gopher Euripides and James' sister Lizzie, Peter sets off on a dangerous quest into the darkness of Evermore!  Little does he know that his actions will have consequences far beyond those he intended as he learns the importance of suffering and sacrifice.